National Forum

Irish Independent Top 20 Players

(Oldest Posts First) - Go To The Latest Post


Wouldn't have considered the paper as great for constructive GAA views but the articles compiled for each county , province and today national of top 20 players for each code is a excellent weeks reading .
Today sees the national top 20 in both hurling and football , delighted to see two Limerick men in it Pat Hartigan and my idea of the best Limerick hurler in my lifetime Eamon Cregan. It is for the past 50 years by the way with no less than 7 Kilkenny players well deserved in the top 20 .
Plenty of debate even at county level about who should or shouldn't be on the best twenty . Well done to those involved in it .

OpenStand (Limerick) - Posts: 293 - 30/05/2020 10:50:41    2279503

Link

Replying To OpenStand:  "Wouldn't have considered the paper as great for constructive GAA views but the articles compiled for each county , province and today national of top 20 players for each code is a excellent weeks reading .
Today sees the national top 20 in both hurling and football , delighted to see two Limerick men in it Pat Hartigan and my idea of the best Limerick hurler in my lifetime Eamon Cregan. It is for the past 50 years by the way with no less than 7 Kilkenny players well deserved in the top 20 .
Plenty of debate even at county level about who should or shouldn't be on the best twenty . Well done to those involved in it ."
Not being Unionist, I don't read the "Irish" "Independent". What's the list?

essmac (Tyrone) - Posts: 796 - 30/05/2020 12:25:28    2279511

Link

Can someone post up the list of the national top 20 footballers and hurlers?

Kerry15 (Kerry) - Posts: 597 - 30/05/2020 13:05:28    2279517

Link

Football:
1. Jack O'Shea
2. Pat Spillane
3. Peter Canavan
4. Stephen Cluxton
5. Mikey Sheehy
6. Matt Connor
7. Brian Mullins
8. Larry Tompkins
9. Colm Cooper
10. John O'Keeffe
11. Michael Murphy
12. Maurice Fitzgerald
13. Sean Cavanagh
14. Colm O'Rourke
15. Seamus Moynihan
16. Padraig Joyce
17. Trevor Giles
18. James McCarthy
19. Brian Fenton
20. Tomas O'Se

Personally would have had Anthony Tohill instead of Cavanagh, and push him and Michael Murphy into the top 10 somehow.

Hurling:
1. Henry Shefflin
2. DJ Carey
3. Brian Whelahan
4. Eddie Keher
5. Tommy Walsh
6. Brian Corcoran
7. Nicky English
8. Joe Canning
9. Seanie McMahon
10. Ken McGrath
11. Joe Cooney
12. Pat Hartigan
13. JJ Delaney
14. Brian Lohan
15. Noel Skehan
16. Eamonn Cregan
17. Eoin Kelly
18. TJ Reid
19. Tony Doran
20. Ray Cummins

Glaring issue there is how low JJ Delaney is. Would swap him with Tommy Walsh (and still have Tommy in the top 10), and move Canning further up the list into the top 5 too. Both Tony Doran and Ray Cummins should be ahead of TJ too in my opinion.

beano (Wexford) - Posts: 598 - 30/05/2020 14:06:14    2279522

Link

Replying To OpenStand:  "Wouldn't have considered the paper as great for constructive GAA views but the articles compiled for each county , province and today national of top 20 players for each code is a excellent weeks reading .
Today sees the national top 20 in both hurling and football , delighted to see two Limerick men in it Pat Hartigan and my idea of the best Limerick hurler in my lifetime Eamon Cregan. It is for the past 50 years by the way with no less than 7 Kilkenny players well deserved in the top 20 .
Plenty of debate even at county level about who should or shouldn't be on the best twenty . Well done to those involved in it ."
Who chose, and how were the players chosen?

Cockney_Cat (UK) - Posts: 1115 - 30/05/2020 15:02:53    2279526

Link

Replying To beano:  "Football:
1. Jack O'Shea
2. Pat Spillane
3. Peter Canavan
4. Stephen Cluxton
5. Mikey Sheehy
6. Matt Connor
7. Brian Mullins
8. Larry Tompkins
9. Colm Cooper
10. John O'Keeffe
11. Michael Murphy
12. Maurice Fitzgerald
13. Sean Cavanagh
14. Colm O'Rourke
15. Seamus Moynihan
16. Padraig Joyce
17. Trevor Giles
18. James McCarthy
19. Brian Fenton
20. Tomas O'Se

Personally would have had Anthony Tohill instead of Cavanagh, and push him and Michael Murphy into the top 10 somehow.

Hurling:
1. Henry Shefflin
2. DJ Carey
3. Brian Whelahan
4. Eddie Keher
5. Tommy Walsh
6. Brian Corcoran
7. Nicky English
8. Joe Canning
9. Seanie McMahon
10. Ken McGrath
11. Joe Cooney
12. Pat Hartigan
13. JJ Delaney
14. Brian Lohan
15. Noel Skehan
16. Eamonn Cregan
17. Eoin Kelly
18. TJ Reid
19. Tony Doran
20. Ray Cummins

Glaring issue there is how low JJ Delaney is. Would swap him with Tommy Walsh (and still have Tommy in the top 10), and move Canning further up the list into the top 5 too. Both Tony Doran and Ray Cummins should be ahead of TJ too in my opinion."
JJ Delaney is the best defender of all time. Joe McKenna was better than Ray Cummins. Is a very good list..few arguments.

bloodyban (Limerick) - Posts: 1323 - 30/05/2020 16:23:20    2279528

Link

Replying To Cockney_Cat:  "Who chose, and how were the players chosen?"
if u read the paper you would know so go back to the soccer

mickcunningham (Westmeath) - Posts: 1243 - 30/05/2020 16:31:12    2279529

Link

Replying To OpenStand:  "Wouldn't have considered the paper as great for constructive GAA views but the articles compiled for each county , province and today national of top 20 players for each code is a excellent weeks reading .
Today sees the national top 20 in both hurling and football , delighted to see two Limerick men in it Pat Hartigan and my idea of the best Limerick hurler in my lifetime Eamon Cregan. It is for the past 50 years by the way with no less than 7 Kilkenny players well deserved in the top 20 .
Plenty of debate even at county level about who should or shouldn't be on the best twenty . Well done to those involved in it ."
I agree Openstand . It was a great concept and it was really well done . They compiled the top twenty footballers for each county, for each province and then today for the country going back to 1970. They did the same for hurling but confined it to the counties that have competed for the Liam NcCarthy on a meaningful basis . I did something this week that I haven't done for many years and that is buy a newspaper every day since Monday . I stopped buying newspapers years ago because I became and remain hugely disillusioned by what masquerades as journalism at national level in Ireland . This was a great concept however and it was really well done . I've taken screen shots of a lot of the teams . They'll be produced when our local hostelries reopen and they'll be the source of animated debate .

Greengrass (Louth) - Posts: 5166 - 30/05/2020 16:36:40    2279530

Link

Replying To bloodyban:  "JJ Delaney is the best defender of all time. Joe McKenna was better than Ray Cummins. Is a very good list..few arguments."
I'm going to go away and have a think about the two lists but I agree with you about JJ. Tommy Walsh won All Stars at left corner back, left half back, right half back, midfield and left half forward . Nobody but nobody comes anywhere near that . I also think Stephen Cluxton at number four in the football list is ranked way too high when you consider James McCarthy and Brian Fenton are only at 18 and 19. I would have those two higher and Cluxton in at 19 or 20.

Greengrass (Louth) - Posts: 5166 - 30/05/2020 16:44:19    2279531

Link

Replying To beano:  "Football:
1. Jack O'Shea
2. Pat Spillane
3. Peter Canavan
4. Stephen Cluxton
5. Mikey Sheehy
6. Matt Connor
7. Brian Mullins
8. Larry Tompkins
9. Colm Cooper
10. John O'Keeffe
11. Michael Murphy
12. Maurice Fitzgerald
13. Sean Cavanagh
14. Colm O'Rourke
15. Seamus Moynihan
16. Padraig Joyce
17. Trevor Giles
18. James McCarthy
19. Brian Fenton
20. Tomas O'Se

Personally would have had Anthony Tohill instead of Cavanagh, and push him and Michael Murphy into the top 10 somehow.

Hurling:
1. Henry Shefflin
2. DJ Carey
3. Brian Whelahan
4. Eddie Keher
5. Tommy Walsh
6. Brian Corcoran
7. Nicky English
8. Joe Canning
9. Seanie McMahon
10. Ken McGrath
11. Joe Cooney
12. Pat Hartigan
13. JJ Delaney
14. Brian Lohan
15. Noel Skehan
16. Eamonn Cregan
17. Eoin Kelly
18. TJ Reid
19. Tony Doran
20. Ray Cummins

Glaring issue there is how low JJ Delaney is. Would swap him with Tommy Walsh (and still have Tommy in the top 10), and move Canning further up the list into the top 5 too. Both Tony Doran and Ray Cummins should be ahead of TJ too in my opinion."
In all fairness in terms of backs, seanie McMahon, Brian Corcoran and pat hartigan were not better than JJ Delaney. As simple as that

In terms of goalkeepers, Noel Skehan was not better than Damien Fitzhenry or Eoin Murphy.

Joe Cooney better by 7 places than TJ? Don't think so.

And no Michael fennelly.

Onfor15 (Wexford) - Posts: 233 - 30/05/2020 17:15:17    2279535

Link

Replying To Onfor15:  "In all fairness in terms of backs, seanie McMahon, Brian Corcoran and pat hartigan were not better than JJ Delaney. As simple as that

In terms of goalkeepers, Noel Skehan was not better than Damien Fitzhenry or Eoin Murphy.

Joe Cooney better by 7 places than TJ? Don't think so.

And no Michael fennelly."
I saw Noel Skehan in every All Ireland final he played from 1972 on . I saw plenty of Damien Fitzhenry and Eoin Murphy . In my opinion and it is only my opinion based on what I saw and what I remember Noel Skehan was a better keeper than either Eoin Murphy or Damien Fitzhenry.

Greengrass (Louth) - Posts: 5166 - 30/05/2020 17:36:55    2279537

Link

Replying To mickcunningham:  "if u read the paper you would know so go back to the soccer"
Not everyone reads the Irish Independent or wants to pay €120 a year to read it online.

GreenandRed (Mayo) - Posts: 5955 - 30/05/2020 18:46:18    2279540

Link

Replying To mickcunningham:  "if u read the paper you would know so go back to the soccer"
There is more than one paper you know or were you aware of that. There is more than one tv station too.

catch22 (USA) - Posts: 1647 - 30/05/2020 19:44:39    2279546

Link

Replying To Cockney_Cat:  "Who chose, and how were the players chosen?"
Martin Breheny in the Irish Independent, not sure if it's his own personal list or if he received input from colleagues.

ballydalane (Kilkenny) - Posts: 1112 - 30/05/2020 21:42:28    2279553

Link

A better reflection on the players then the Sunday game team.

gatha (Kilkenny) - Posts: 183 - 30/05/2020 21:42:35    2279554

Link

Brian Whelehan has to be top of the list and Eoin Kelly has to be in top 7 at a minimum. Paudie Maher also gets into the top 20 without a shadow of a doubt

tiobraid (Tipperary) - Posts: 2911 - 31/05/2020 16:24:09    2279598

Link

Picking the 20 best footballers is a difficult task and the result depends more on the guy who picks it. You could easily add another 20 who are as good. A few who come to mind! G. Geraghty, J. Eagan, J. B. Murphy. Big Donaghy who at his best was unbeatable, I could go on. Brian McGuigan senior who could play at midfield, CF and FF has to be up there with the best and exceptionally skill full who could score equally well with either foot taking the normal abuse of the day . He scored 11 points from play in an Ulster final against Armagh -not sure of the year (late 70's early 80's-on youtube). Every county has had some very good footballers, some with a higher profile which helps the media.

browncows (Meath) - Posts: 2189 - 03/06/2020 13:02:33    2279809

Link

Replying To browncows:  "Picking the 20 best footballers is a difficult task and the result depends more on the guy who picks it. You could easily add another 20 who are as good. A few who come to mind! G. Geraghty, J. Eagan, J. B. Murphy. Big Donaghy who at his best was unbeatable, I could go on. Brian McGuigan senior who could play at midfield, CF and FF has to be up there with the best and exceptionally skill full who could score equally well with either foot taking the normal abuse of the day . He scored 11 points from play in an Ulster final against Armagh -not sure of the year (late 70's early 80's-on youtube). Every county has had some very good footballers, some with a higher profile which helps the media."
You are talking about Frank McGuigan browncows. He was the father of Brian and Tommy . The match you are talking about is the Ulster Final of 1984.

Greengrass (Louth) - Posts: 5166 - 03/06/2020 13:20:17    2279810

Link

I probably couldn't put Frank McGuigan on a list of the 20 best players of the last 50 years. He lived in the States for 6 years between the ages of 22-28, and a car crash ended his career when he was 30. Certainly there were many moments of exceptional brilliance when he was at home, but it would be unfair to rank him ahead of some other all-time greats in terms of accomplishments over a full career.

So, simply because his career was so short, Frank McGuigan probably would not be on my list of the Top 20 players of the last 50 years. But, if I was listing the most gifted and talented players in that period, he'd be No.1. In terms of footballing ability, Frank McGuigan was peerless. He was the very best.

Thomas Clarke (Tyrone) - Posts: 1002 - 03/06/2020 19:13:27    2279845

Link

TJ Reid is obviously brilliant but am I the only one who thinks he's not top 20 of the last 50yrs brilliant?

Breezy (Limerick) - Posts: 1106 - 04/06/2020 09:54:41    2279869

Link